|
Editor's Note: Splendid's Bookshelf promises a consistent guide to the best in independent
and small press publishing. Thousands of books are released each year by
presses representing communities and viewpoints not always found in your
local MegaBookMart. Each month, Bookshelf will spotlight a different press,
with reviews of fiction, poetry, cultural writing and more, providing a
valuable guide for those interested in expanding their reading horizons.
· · · · · · ·
Leela Patel, Smell's first-person narrator, is a difficult
character to love. She's fragile, unsure of herself and constantly gauging
other people's reactions, not to mention self-absorbed. She clings to men,
with whom she forms unhealthy romantic attachments. Although the flap copy
bills the book as a tale of self-invention, Leela's colorful story has less
to do with her own actions and decisions and more to do with her reactions
to what other people see in her, or wish her to do; her life is an oddly
assorted array of incidents. Rarely does she take decisive
action, or make a decision of any kind.
The book opens with the death of Leela's father, a storekeeper in Mombassa,
Kenya, in a firebombing attack. Leela's mother divides the now destitute
family, sending Leela to live with an aunt and uncle who own an
epicerie in Paris, while moving herself and Leela's twin younger
brothers to live with another uncle in England. Leela's Uncle Krishenbhai
and Aunty Latha are the novel's first quasi-villains; as soon as Leela
arrives in Paris, they confiscate her passport. Leela works in her uncle's
store, taking over the books and covering for her uncle's adulterous
liaisons in the back room. Then she heads home and cooks dinner for Aunty Latha (in the process becoming an
accomplished cook), who suffers from mysterious and possibly
imaginary ailments and spends most of her days lying around their airless,
overheated banlieue apartment, watching Indian movies. Leela is not
allowed to go out alone, and her relatives see but one other couple. Their
daughter Lotti becomes Leela's only friend. Born and bred in Paris,
confident and sophisticated, Lotti takes the time to teach Leela French,
shows her around the city, makes her comfortable with the metro, the
museums, the shape of daily life in France. It is Lotti who comforts Leela
when Leela's mother remarries and makes it plain that there is no room in
her life for a grown daughter.
When Leela is thrown out after a blowup -- faulted by her uncle for leaving
the store while he needed guarding, Leela tells her Aunty Latha the truth
about his indiscretions -- Lotti introduces her to Maeve, a beautiful
part-time model and full-time party girl who allows Leela to stay with her
for a time. Penniless, and lacking both passport and self-confidence, Leela
doesn't view her change in scene as a liberation: "Sudden freedom made me
apathetic," she says. Finding only odd jobs, she writes to her mother,
begging to be allowed to come to England; she's told to return to her aunt
and uncle and beg forgiveness. It is the last time her mother is heard from.
Leela passes days on end sitting on the apartment's balcony, watching
the crowds below, until Maeve arranges for her to work as an au pair
for an acquaintance.
Thus starts what might be considered the strongest part of the book.
Leela begins an affair with Bruno Baleine, the father of the house, and cares for his small children. She befriends a few other
Parisians -- among them Olivier, a sensitive type who takes her to concerts
and plays classical music for her, gently educating her. It's in this
section of the book that the titular odor appears.
Leela first notices it while stopping at her favorite patisserie: "A
dark feral smell, too strong to be civilized, too powerful to be hidden. A
smell so shameless, it belonged to the night or to those private moments of
solitude that cannot be shared." A moment later she realizes that the smell
is coming from her: "I sat down quickly and draped my sweater over my groin.
I had found the source of the smell." She tries to mask it with cleanliness,
perfume and soap. Her sexual awareness comes at a price: Bruno desires her
for her exotic looks. He will make love to her, but he will never leave his
wife. Leela becomes convinced that the Baleines will eventually realize that
she smells and dismiss her.
At a party, Leela meets Phillippe Lavalle, the impresario of a chain of food
stores, and begins a whirlwind romance, leaving the Baleine household and
taking up residence in Phillippe's luxurious apartment. Phillippe finally
obtains for her a duplicate of her confiscated passport, and they travel,
making passionate love along the way. Leela's keen sense of smell, her
sensuality and her discerning taste excite the food entrepreneur, but his
success depends on the visual aspects of food, not the olfactory ones.
Desperate to keep his attention, Leela invents a sex game in which she
describes in minute detail how all the various parts of his body smell. But
while their relationship (three years, compressed in a small space in the
novel) provides her with material comfort, it does not make her independent.
Phillippe leaves her alone for long stretches, and she paces the apartment,
feeling sorry for herself. Finally, Phillippe humiliates Leela, admitting to
her that he despises smells. "Smell is dirty, unclean, unspoken, that's why
it's exciting, erotic, savage, like you," he tells Leela. "You, my sweet,
are a little savage. And savages have no morals. That's why you still excite
me, after all these years." Unable to hurt him in any other way, she tells
him that she has made up all the scents that go along with their sex game.
"You have no special smell," she tells him. "I made it all up."
Then he beats her, of course, finally prompting her to leave him. In an
American novel, Leela would never look back -- but this is not an American novel. Instead, she
leaves only temporarily, expecting Phillippe to miss her and come looking
for her. When she tries to see him again, she is rebuffed. Fifteen
thousand francs are deposited into a bank account for her, and she is warned
that if she does not leave him alone, Phillippe's attorney will revoke her
residency permit.
Jobless and alone, Leela tracks down her old friend Olivier, who, after a
half hour of wariness, takes her in; it seems he has loved her all along.
But what to do for work? Leela falls in with a marketing company and becomes
"the fusion food queen of Paris", but it all goes sour again. Suffering a
bizarre episode, convinced that she will be forced out of her marketing
company because of the smell, she finds herself hiding out in the metro,
like the rats who have fascinated her throughout the book. She rescues an
itinerant puppeteer from a beating. He gets her story out of her. "You don't
smell," he tells her. "It is only your fear talking. You want to think that
you smell, because then you do not have to struggle anymore. That way no one
else will be able to hurt you, because you have already rejected yourself,
you have already thrown away your self-respect."
In a way, the novel is about a girl who lands on her feet despite her own
inherent passivity. Is it Jha's desire to go to great lengths to show that
Leela is a "good" girl, only doing "bad" things when she is in the wrong
hands? Excepting her reunion with Olivier, Leela never makes the first move
in a relationship, allowing men to manipulate her; her work papers are
obtained for her by men, and she takes jobs proposed to her by men rather than
seeking out employment on her own. Women are alien creatures who either like or dislike Leela,
but have little to do with her life. Is Leela's passivity intended to show
the helplessness of the alien in a hostile society, unable to take
things into her own hands? The novel ends on an upbeat note, as Leela turns
her feet back towards Olivier, who is waiting for her. "I am going home,"
she says. But after three hundred pages of angst and insecurity, the
two-page resolution feels forced. I wish that I had been able to see
her go home, rather than have her tell it to me.
-- Cristen Brooks has edited numerous books for
publication, and currently works for print management software provider
PrintCafe when not practicing her karate. · · · · · · ·
About the Publisher: Soho Press
Soho Press is an independent publisher based in New York City. Since 1987,
they've sought to publish literary fiction and quality nonfiction by new
writers
in America, the U.K., and elsewhere. Their Soho Crime imprint features
hardcover
and paperback novels featuring foreign settings, local noir and unusual
investigators.
|