Made up of outtakes from For Stars and Windows For Stars, the band's
first two US albums, Airline People stands as a strong testament
to the strength of For Stars' material. Carlos Forster is a master of
melody, and he sounds like a softer-spoken version of Jackson Browne. Like
Browne, the band's home is California; their instrumentation, though
stripped to basics, also bears similarities to Browne's early classics, and the light Caribbean touches make me wonder if David Lindley made a
guest appearance. The most beautiful song on this 15-minute EP is
"Brown Skin Saint". It boasts a simple but beautiful chorus ("We have
dreams/They make us laugh/We have guns/They make us cry"), and Forster's
vocals are at their most yearning and sincere. "Motorway" carries a similar
impact, but the light harmony vocals make it a touch prettier (for better
and worse). With each song, I found myself marvelling over Forster's lyrical
skills; unlike most songwriters, who kill to be clever, he uses words
sparsely, suggesting that his sole intent is to create a good song. It's
the
best approach a songwriter can take, and the it's the reason why Forster's songs feel
like poetry -- good poetry.
In these short songs alone, Forster warrants a devoted cult of people who
feel, and might well be, "too sensitive" for the world. And yet there is
one troubling spot: a lyrical misstep which occurs during "The Racecar Driving Scene". This majestically sung ballad, which starts off at a slow heartbeat, contains this this quick little jab: "I joined
the Christians/In the attempt that I'd be found/I had no money/So they ran
me out of town." It makes me wonder if John Lennon's remark, "God is a
concept by which we measure our pain," was pop music's last interesting critique of religion. I'll subtract nothing from the praise which
came before, but it's a shame that even music's most gifted and astute
lyricists repeatedly collapse into cliche when dropping their thoughts on
faith.
Should Forster start to use his gifts of introspection across all of life's
main subjects, there will be no good reason for a music fan to bypass any
For Stars release. It is songs like his which bring light to the sky and
reveal reasons why we are fragile underneath.