In the summer of 1990, I had one of the best weeks ever. In a seven day
period, I saw Nine Inch Nails, Erasure and Peter Murphy in concert. While
NIN was the most intense show and Erasure was the most fun, Murphy was the
most moving. With his luxurious baritone and knack for poetic composition,
the man had the entire crowd eating from his imperious hand. The sense of
beauty he created still haunts me years later, so I approached his latest
release, a live show from Los Angeles, with eager anticipation.
From the opening tune, "Cool, Cool Breeze", the emotion of that distant
summer night immediately rushes back. Performed a capella, the song compels the listener to zero in on the meaning and movement of Murphy's words. When
he sings "These words I know are bound and stuck," the crowd calls out at
the contradiction between the text's meaning and its lively tone. When he
holds his note on the line "With you I'm in no danger," Murphy connects
instantly with the crowd; the line takes on a double meaning in which he
thanks his adoring audience. As this sinks in, the crowd erupts at the gap
revealed in Murphy's otherwise severe emotional armor.
Such emotional disclosures were the primary goal of this recording. By
featuring his tunes both live and stripped down, Murphy sought to find
something new, both in himself and in his music. While I don't know if the
experiment paid off for his soul, it certainly succeeded musically. Some
tracks, such as "Marlene Dietrich's Favourite Poem", were relatively sparse
in their studio versions, and therefore benefit mainly from the added passion of
the live performance. Others are elevated by paring their instrumentation
down to the basics. Hugh Marsh's (he has backed Rod Stewart and Soul
Asylum) electric violin gives the main melody of "Cuts You Up" more depth
than the original's synthesized line, while Peter DiStefano (Porno for
Pyros) holds down the guitars nicely. Also, by eliminating the drums,
keyboards and tapes that have backed him in the past, Murphy is forced to
invest more of himself in the performance than he otherwise might have done.
This makes the songs absolutely shimmer. Some tracks are even rescued from
lackluster studio performances; in particular, the version of "Indigo
Eyes" found here far outstrips the original. In fact, it is so
delightful that I'm willing to forgive Murphy for the horrific remix of the
song he included on his Roll Call EP.
The second disc contains a scant four tracks, but they are likely to cause the
most furor, as they feature Murphy playing with his former Bauhaus
collaborator, David J. Three of the numbers, "Who Killed Mr. Moonlight",
"All We Ever Wanted" and "Hope", are culled from the pair's Bauhaus glory
days. The fourth is a menacing version of Elvis Presley's "Love Me
Tender". On a musical scale, these tracks don't match the beauty of the
first disc's contents, but come on -- it's freaking Bauhaus! If you
have never spent much time with Murphy, this disc presents an excellent
entry point. By combining both past and current gems, it shows off
Murphy's achievements as a songwriter and performer. Furthermore, by
highlighting the sheer volume of passion and vision that still wells from the man, it
shows just how much more we can hope for in the future.