If you're unfamiliar with Encapsulated’s premise, please allow me to bring you up to speed. This is a "new" Metroschifter album, but Metroschifter does not appear on it. Performing newly written Metroschifter songs in their place is a hand-picked roster of bands, most of whom you know if not love. After assigning a songs to each band, Metroschifter leader Scott Richter sent his bandmates-by-proxy a rough demo cassette, printed lyrics and a modest recording
budget. Now, more than two years later, the results of this ground-breaking exercise have been
chronicled on Encapsulated.
I knew this album was going to be a pick long before I'd heard it. “How did you know?”, you're probably wondering. Well, I'll tell you: any band that has the balls to organize a
tribute to themselves is more than deserving of pick status in
my book. As far as I know, the only other soul with the guts to
pull a stunt like this is Stephin Merritt (with his notorious 6ths
project), and I gather that nearly blew up in his face. I long
ago proclaimed Merritt to be a genius and I now bestow that same honor
upon Scott Richter.
The big names on Encapsulated deliver their
well-known musical goods. The Get Up Kids turn “Impossible
Outcomes” into a strident, new-wave inflected rocker, while the Promise
Ring slather “You are So Unreal” in distorted and fed-back guitars,
then stack a huge helping of melody and Davey’s vocals on top just for
good measure. Tim Kinsella and sensitive art-punks Joan of Arc
manage to deftly slow down, vilify, then inject large doses of humility
into “Forensic Economics”. Other standouts include Cooler’s raging
guitar slug-fest “Downschifter,” the Enkindels’ paean to power-punk
“Burn Lexington Burn” as well as Elliott’s programming enhanced
slow-burner “Isn’t Freedom a Poison”. But it’s a pair of stripped-down acoustic offerings that allows Richter’s songwriting prowess to shine the most.
Burning Airlines and Refused, two bands known for their uncompromising
and unhinged sound, contribute gorgeous acoustic renditions to
Encapsulated. J. Robbins and company diligently pick and strum their
way through “Dear Hilary” while defunct Swedish noise terrorists Refused
strip down to vocals, skeletal acoustic guitar and piano for the utterly
lovely “L-182”.
Though it’s the bands appearing on Encapsulated that will receive the
majority of the praise, Richter’s smart, poignant songwriting
is the real shining star. Without his musical craftsmanship
this album would have never left the ground. Encapsulated proves
Metroschifter to be a band truly deserving of this most stunning of
tributes.