No, Neutral Milk Hotel hasn't turned folk, and no, Elliott Smith
hasn't abandoned his baroque pop stylings. The music on this second volume
of the Home series of collaborations, brought to us by Austin's Post-Parlo
Records, brings such ideas to mind. Scott Garred of Silver Scooter (aka Super XX Man) and Tiara's Eric Rottmayer (aka Eric
Metronome), have crafted that precious, gentle breed of folk that has become all the rage.
Yeah, yeah -- think Belle and Sebastian without the accent and
the super-clean production. Since Belle and Sebastian haven't put
out a quality release since If You're Feeling Sinister, it's
really up to everybody else to put together cohesive folk-pop albums.
That's just what Garred and Rottmayer do here. It's not flashy, it's
never pretentious and it's simply quite good.
The two collaborators have penned four songs apiece for Home: Volume II,
and they play two covers as well (one of which is the Softies' "Fragile, Don't Crush"). Rottmayer's tracks tend to be more elaborate, while Garred's
almost suggest Crayon in their absolute tweeness. These are the most
twee-sounding folk songs you're likely to come across.
"See You See" might be the album's finest moment. Through fragile, sweet
wordplay and a quietly strummed guitar, Rottmayer documents a touching
expression in a relationship. The Softies cover sees the duo harmonizing
in a manner that's best labeled cute.
The collaboration is quite a success. It makes you want to explore the
two artists' "primary" bands, to look into past and future
Home editions, and to dig deeper into Post Parlo's apparently quite
decent stable of bands. In short, Home: Volume II is a nice, accomplished surprise.