Will Oldham's place in history will be cemented in
the montage hall; wedged somewhere between Whiskeytown
and Edith Frost, a freshly carved stone will read
"Will Oldham aka Palace aka Bonnie 'Prince' Billy
aka Bonny Billy combined the early '90s lo-fi
aesthetic with the unassuming -- get to the
point -- structure of the heartland's greatest country
songwriters." Of course, Oldham's ability to construct music
that matters in a genre that seemingly doesn't (at
least as far as much of his potential audience is concerned) indicates
opposing forces at work; after all, you'll never see
Tim McGraw or John Philips gain underground acclaim.
Newly rechristened Bonny Billy (it beats 0{+>, I guess), Oldham gives us
More Revery. The aptly titled ode to influence
is an Ira Kaplan grab bag of covers running the
musical gamut from P.J. Harvey to John Holt.
Originally released as a tour-only EP, the disc, now available
"over the counter", is some of the best material
the Bonny Billy camp has released in years.
The album opens with a cover of "Someone's Sleeping", by Mamas and Papas founder John Philips. The
short piano ballad recalls Oldham's somber and stately
perspectives, with a contemporary slant that tilts its
thematic head towards the more subdued Palace efforts.
The album's standout track comes next -- a version
of P.J. Harvey's "Sweeter Than Anything". While the
band keeps with the Polly Jean dynamics, the song is
stripped of its original precision and the production
is fuzzed up a little. These minute alterations give
the track an entirely new feel, while retaining the
uninhibited emotion and "I'm mad and I'm not going to
take it!" attitude that made it great in the first
place.
The rest of the album follows in the same
style, matching Oldham's vocal repose with an
unhindered melodic intensity and giving new life to a
collection of songs that had been written off for
years. The only notable disappointment is John
Holt's "Strange Things", in which Oldham's usual vocal
excellence is so drenched in irksome reverb effects
that the melody is stripped of any plausible value.