On his first release in two years, Matt Schickele shows us an artist at the
top of his game. Over the course of twelve tracks, Schickele's music is
confident, bold and always engaging. While all of the playing is solid,
the real appeal here lies in Schickele's ability to strike a mood. Each song
is self-sufficient and complete, so on a track-by-track level the disc is successful -- but a greater pleasure comes from listening to Cities Filled With Lights as a whole. At this level, it yields the same satisfaction as a great collection of short stories: individual pleasures
are enhanced by unraveling the hidden threads that run through the
seemingly separate units. Thus, while I can describe some of the delights
of the individual tracks, you won't understand the true extent of the album's
joys until you dissect it for yourself.
For starters, consider the opening track, "Above the Air". On this song,
Schickele's guitar sounds like a set of chimes, imbuing the song with a
festive, holiday feel. During the verses, the instrumentation is reduced
to a minimum, with simple bass notes keeping time as the guitar gently
jingles in the background. When the vocals are given this much
breathing room, Schickele's subdued voice is almost overwhelmed by the
sonic panorama surrounding it, making lyrical statements like "the city's awful" all the more
brazen. This charming track makes a fine beginning by clueing listeners in
to the subtleties they'll find in Schickele's deceptively simple tracks.
The merriment of the first track is contrasted by "Enemies
Like Enemies". Here, Schickele strikes a weary march through harshly
struck guitar strings and well-placed piano lines. Emphasizing the
unpleasantness of the song's thrust, the vocals push into the falsetto as
they call out "Enemies like enemies/ to fill in the pieces they skipped" -- which, by combining unadorned acoustic guitar with ominous military
imagery, calls to mind The Wall-era Pink Floyd. "Maybe" is
propelled by an uptempo, frantic guitar that is countered during the chorus
by a sedated piano. On this number, Schickele's vocal line draws a
favorable comparison to Mark Eitzel's poetic sound.
"Bodega" and "Split the Clouds" also stand out. The first
track is the instrumental raving of a manic carnival piano, which abruptly
settles into the comping base for the second song. During "Split the
Clouds", Schickele again uses his courageous falsetto. This time, however,
instead of John Waters, he reminds me of Chris Connelly's solo work, an
image that is heightened by the harmonica solo.
Track by track, my appreciation for Schickele grows. By the time the disc
reaches its closing title track, a broken-down folk number that offers the
advice "cities filled with lights cannot offer it all", Schickele has
completely broken free of his previous work with indie-rock outfit
Beekeeper. What remains is a mature musician who has no difficulty in
drawing others into his music -- and an hour of tunes that do exactly
that.