The problem with being as consistently good as Kristin Hersh is that
people eventually stop recognizing your accomplishments. In the twenty
years since she formed the Throwing Muses, at age 14, Hersh has produced
an astonishing body of work; drawing on Appalachian folk songs just as
heavily as on the Ramones, her songs, as she puts it, "express
themselves strongly." On her third solo album, Sunny Border
Blue, Hersh plays all of the instruments and produces herself to
stunningly ferocious effect. Even without a band behind her -- the
Muses split in 1997 due to financial difficulties -- Hersh
can fill a room with her voice, with quiet exactitude or harsh anger.
Songs like the album-opening "Your Dirty Answer" lay bare wounds which
sound raw: "It's not my fault/It's not my fault you don't love me," she
sings with seemingly righteous indignation, before the next phrase
admits its own culpability, adding, "When I'm drunk." The floral album
title promises a silver lining, and one is occasionally visible. "Spain"
begins with a lazy, jazz-guitar evocation of a holiday abroad, with
Hersh recalling "Blindfolded kissing/looking for the truth in your tiny
moves."
Halfway through the song, though, the one man band takes over and the
bile comes back. In a passive-aggressive line rivaling Bob Dylan's "I
wish that for just one time you could stand inside my shoes/You'd know
what a drag it is to see you," Hersh sings, "I wanted you to sleep with
her and hate yourself/Instead of me." Some see too much melodrama in
Hersh's lyrics, but she's rarely less than razor sharp in her observations;
she insists that the bad stuff in her songs is only the things she doesn't
want in her own personality, but it's hard to avoid the immediacy in the
delivery of bitter lines like, "How many times can you get fucked/In how
many different ways?" In a mediated culture that disapproves of pain
(unless it's being inflicted on someone else), Hersh insists on
including the blood and guts of real life. Addiction, heartache,
regret, frustration, joy -- these songs tap darker universals, not the
buffed cross-marketing gleam of Britney Spears and Aerosmith cavorting
at the Super Bowl.
As a producer, Hersh outshines many of the bigger names in the
business. A clear, well-arranged sound gives the mainly acoustic
instruments an impressive heft and volume. Brilliant details fill in
open spaces, like the multi-tracked backing vocal to "Your Dirty
Answer", which echoes the angelic pitch of the background singers on
Hendrix's "Hey Joe". When Hersh performs, her eyes stare through
the back wall and her head weaves like a snake about to strike. You can feel that intensity in her playing as well; the album sounds amazingly organic despite its multi-tracked nature. This vibrant energy is also extended to Hersh's occasional cover tunes; Cat Stevens' "Trouble" sounds so natural
coming out of her mouth that you'll wonder why she didn't record it sooner. She may not cheer you up, but Hersh will hold your hand while
you're looking at the rain.