Through her band Sarge, Elizabeth Elmore's songs created one of the most authentic
female personas in the last decade of music. Tough, gracious, sensuous,
serious and always forthright, the woman portrayed by the lyrics was as
sharply drawn as a character in a Lorrie Moore novel, yet without Moore's
tendency to soften the harsher moments with humor.
The final Sarge release, Distant, has wisely been divided into four
sections. The three last studio demos that feature the full band lineup (Chad
Romanski, Sue Roth, Derek Niedringhaus, and Elizabeth) could all fit nicely
amongst other classic Sarge songs. Each of them, but especially "Detroit
Star-Lite" and "Clearer", carries the same swift rush of emotion as is found on "Beguiling" from their classic Glass Intact album. The lyrics give a very clear impression that July 1999 was a bad
relationship month!
The live tracks, added partly to boost the size of the album, come from
their dates opening for Braid, a band which shared a similar love of and
devotion to emotional music. The audience noise is kept to a
minimum, making the songs serve mostly as a rough sampler for all whose
music libraries lack Sarge's first two offerings.
All the live songs are wonderful versions, I should add, but especially "Half As
Far", which builds to a weightier conclusion through its rawer performance.
A highlight for many will be the covers. Wham's "Last Days of Christmas",
chosen for possibly frivolous reasons, still proves the perfect song for
Sarge to redo. They inject it with the energy and soul George Michael always
shied from and make it my second favorite 80's cover (next to Class' "We
Don't Have To Take Our Clothes Off"). For Cyndi Lauper's "Time After Time",
Sarge adds surging guitars to the arrangement, but not exactly to the song's
benefit. While wonderful in its own right, it's surprisingly less emotional
than Cyndi's original version. "These Boots Are Made For Walkin'", in
contrast, is more emotional than Nancy Sinatra's version, and quite a winner.
The best news for Sarge fans is that the final songs -- a short, stark title
track and a stunning acoustic rendering of "The End of July", now retitled
"All My Plans Changed..." -- are powerful indications that the peaks have not all been reached, either for Elizabeth or for the other members of Sarge.