This is a very accomplished solo project from Michael Barrett, a busy
young guy who's been drummer-songwriter-singer for Guppyboy, the Essex
Green and the Sixth Great Lake, as well as a touring bassist for Ladybug
Transistor. Against the rest of the Elephant 6 Collective, his outfits have
been among their least hyped, but they are fabulously unpretentious, fun
and worth checking out -- especially if you're a fan of the Kinks' Village
Green phase. With Couches and Carpet, Barrett has made an epic
Donovan throwback that works, like Donovan's music, as a counterpoint to Bob
Dylan, Lou Reed and other poets of the street.
Over eighteen songs, two bonus tracks and more than sixty minutes, Barrett's
individually modest strengths gel into some of the most
consistently pleasing folk pop I've heard. The melodies are sharp, the
music playful and the vocals as soothing as a Monkees TV marathon
on a sick day. It's as if Barrett is trying to make listeners happy or get them to
feel better -- even when he's just doting upon allusions to songs gone
by ("Spanish boots of leather lying in the hall") and to the definitively
mundane ("I step on someone's foot/And they say Ouch"). Like Donovan, he's
eager both to reference Dylan (Bob, not Jakob) and to separate himself from
Dylan. His sometimes poetic lyrics are beautiful, but in a
"serviceable" manner. It's hard to explain, but individual lyric lines are
beautiful ("I'm somewhat sad about staying home"; "Don't forget about me";
"Your dress was fiery red") in the context of their songs, and seemingly commonplace
outside of them. It's Barrett's modesty and his matter-of-fact truths that power
them, as well as his very sincere vocals. He interprets his lyrics as Billie Holiday approached her material, which ultimately means that some material ("Do
you know how many times you fucked your head up? /Just a couple, a couple of
million") succeeds on good intentions alone.
For fans of the more psychedelic side of the E6 Collective, the pleasures
are less bountiful. You'll find them in numbers like "Queen Cherry Red"
(which incorporates a chase scene music reminiscent of a gripping Get Smart
moment) and "Four Nicks Up" (which also pays homage to the "Wrapping"-era Lou Reed, if
you can imagine). Barrett's heart is more deeply contained in the folk pop;
his gentle earnestness helps familiar-sounding tracks like
"Upstairs in My Room" and "Roll on Home" to remain fresh and fun. The
latter closes the documented portion of the record, injecting innocence
into its blend of "Willin" and "Can't Find My Way Home", while the "Room"
song does everything that "In My Room" and other of its classic precedents
achieved: beautiful yearning guitar licks, tender vocals and small, simple
sentences joined at the hip of nostalgia and melancholia.
The pronouncements made throughout Couches and Carpet are never that
deep ("There's a band in town at the Mercury Lounge/And they're gonna need a
place to stay"), but pop doesn't demand profundities. All it needs is honesty -- and that's what we get throughout this pure and simple pleasure.