Look at the packaging for a moment. If aliens came to earth and hatched a
fiendish plot to control the minds of music fans genre by genre, this is the
package they'd develop to rope the post-rock folks in. It's downright
quintessential,
from the stark, geometrical loneliness of the cover photo to the
snickeringly
oblique in-jokes disguised as song titles. You could put Plays
Music into the
Smithsonian on the strength of its packaging alone.
Having seen the package, if you think you have a pretty good idea what
Plays Music
sounds like, you're probably right. 33.3 are blithely acting out their
musical vignettes on the
thin line between trendiness and flat-out cliche, and in the end it's mostly
the sheer passion
of their performance that keeps them on the right side of that border.
Guitar and drums provide the stuff we've heard before -- loose-knit,
semi-improvised
instrumental rock songs filtered through a precise, jazz-inflected
tempo. Trumpet, trombone, cello
and double bass fill in the "voices" and textures, and this is where
Plays Music derives
its individuality. Dominique Davison's cello lends warmth to all it
touches, its earthy
chords giving humanity to the mathematical progression of "Power
Failure at the U.N.",
and sliding a gentle sentimentality into the background of "An Open
Letter to Buckminster
Fuller". Meanwhile, horn player Joseph Grimm provides the album with its
emotional center,
easing his instrument's strident tones into the cocktail-flavored "The Odds", then
alternating between
melodic pathfinding and guitar-taunting repetition on "Oval Cast as
Circle".
I'm not casting
any aspersions on Brian Alfred's guitar work, but those palpable
interactions between
cello, double bass and horns -- when you can actually feel the bow scraping
across the strings and
hear the horn blare with more urgency than the piece requires -- will
always give me the
chills. Davison, Grimm and double bassist William Noland sound like
they're having far
too good a time to bother maintaining the aura of intense concentration
common to this genre.
If you have any doubts about Noland, don't worry -- he comes into his
own on the frenetic
"Super Eight".
Plays Music isn't unique. Anyone who owns a Slint record could probably cite a
few dozen sound-alikes, or at least sound-a-lot-likes. We can either proceed on the assumption
that all
of those albums, including Plays Music, are trend-aping
knockoffs, and write
off the lot of them, or we can follow a more challenging and satisfying
path, listening
for the unique and special aspects of each album. Plays Music
sounds like stuff
you've heard before, but there's a special, vibrant joy between its
notes. It's easy to find
if you look for it.