Who'd've thunk that Thalia Zedek, whose previous projects have included the
likes of the dirgey, bluesy post-punk of Come and the pure sonic assault of
Live Skull, could turn around and create an album this subtle and beautiful?
Been Here and Gone is Zedek's first solo effort; it evolved
out of a series of live shows that she played with pianist Beth Heinberg and
viola player David Michael Curry. These shows, which originally consisted
mostly of covers of songs by artists as diverse as Leonard Cohen, Alex
Chilton and the Ramones, elicited a very strong, positive response from
audiences. With that encouragement, Zedek decided to try her hand at writing
some of her own songs in this new, more laid-back style. Taking the
aforementioned Heinberg and Curry, as well as former Come guitarist Chris
Brokaw, drummer Daniel Coughlin and pianist Mel Lederman into the studio
with her, Zedek set about making a record to document these new songs.
The results are nothing short of stunning. To be honest, I was never a fan
of any of Zedek's former bands -- they were always just a bit too sludgy and
murky for me to appreciate. However, in this new context, stripped of sonic
debris, Zedek's songwriting and arranging skills reveal themselves to be
extremely impressive. The album draws many cues from Leonard Cohen; in
addition to covering one of his songs ("Dance Me to the End of Love"), she
also models a song after one of his -- the opening "Excommunications
(Everybody Knows)" not only shares a parenthetical title with Cohen's
"Everybody Knows", but also overlaps some lyrics and melodic motifs -- and
the album as a whole is similar in tone to his torchy, intimate offerings.
While the disc maintains a sleepy, laid back vibe, there is still
plenty of tension and release to be had. The nearly seven-minute-long
"Desanctified (Full Circle)" starts out with a spare, bluesy, ominous
guitar figure, which slowly builds into a full-band effort, filled out
magnificently with swirling viola and crashing drums. When Zedek delivers
the song's key line -- "Grace, did you desert me/just 'cause I was
flirting with the past" -- in her strong, gravelly alto, the regret is
palpable.
In addition to the Cohen cover, Zedek also covers two more obscure tunes --
the stark, haunting "1926", which was originally done by early '80s Boston
band V, and bossa nova artist Luiz Bonfa's "Manha de Carnival". Interesting
selections, to be sure, but to Zedek's credit, you wouldn't necessarily know
that any of these tunes were covers unless you happened to look at the
writing credits. "1926", in particular, ranks as one of the best tracks on
the album. A ghostlike piano ballad with a lamenting chorus of "your god
hates me", this song will stick with you like the residue of a particularly
vivid dream.
There are many other standout tracks here -- "Back to School" and "Temporary
Guest" are particularly noteworthy -- but the fact is that this is an
end-to-end solid album without a weak track in sight. Been Here and
Gone sets the perfect tone for a lonely night of introspection. Like the
best work of fellow beautiful-gloom-mongers such as the aforementioned Leonard
Cohen and Mark Eitzel, Zedek has created an album that, like a straight shot
of bourbon, may not necessarily make you feel good, but will sure as hell
make you feel better.