Poor Matthew Jacobson. Ever since I learned that Baxendale
would be on Le Grand Magistery in the US, I've been pestering the
Magistery honcho for a
copy of You Will Have Your Revenge. I'm sure he's
been cursing my name
over the last few weeks, especially for its regular
appearances in his e-mail
inbox.
My enthusiasm for You Will Have Your Revenge is a
little bit odd, as
Baxendale isn't the sort of group I usually like. Their
sound is unabashedly
retro-leaning Eurotechnodisco -- sort of a less fey Pet
Shop Boys fronted by
Howard Devoto. It's bouncy, cheerfully mainstream music;
like many of their peers,
Baxendale may have found an American home on an independent
label, but they'd probably
be more comfortable with a fresh-faced nightclub crowd than a
group of fanatical Momus fans.
It's obvious from the first track -- the superlative "Music
for Girls" -- that
Baxendale aren't afraid to perform dressed in silver
jumpsuits, or to dance behind
their own keyboards, taking pleasure in their own cheerily
upbeat bleeps.
It's no secret that this trio loves -- really loves
-- dance music. It's
asserted plainly in "Music for Girls", then rammed home by a
lengthy, affectionate
monologue in "I Love the Sound of Dance Music". This is a
point at which culture
plays an important role. Would you believe an ostensibly
straight twenty-something
American boy gushing about dance music on one hand and
longing for girls on the
other? It probably wouldn't ring true -- the image doesn't
seem to jibe well with the
American music-listening zeitgeist, which allows young
heterosexual men to be just as obsessive, but not as effusive. Not where dance music is concerned, anyway -- it's more the province of indiepop fanboys, which perhaps offers insight into Baxendale's presence on Le Grand Magistery. Regardless, this cultural split helps
vocalist Tim Benton to
create a completely believable, quintessentially British
character -- a veritable
twenty-first century boy, enamoured of video games,
computers, drum machines, cellular phones and, most of all, modern girls -- while
distrusting the crusty trapings
of nasty grotty old rock-and-roll. The ideal Baxendale
woman is as
comfortable in front of a Playstation 2 as she is dancing in
a nightclub ("Neato");
if she claims not to know much about computers or the 'net,
it might well be a
cunningly coy plan to get closer to her chosen man. But
while she's sophisticated,
she's also one of the boys -- as game for a bit of mischief as she is for a
jet-setting holiday
("Hanging Out With Her").
For Tim's character to work, there must be obstacles in
his road. If he's
not trapped beneath the weight of unrequited love, chances
are he's just made --
or thinks he's made -- some foolish misstep that has nipped
a promising relationship
in the bud. If by chance he's got things right, he's
overwhelmed by emotion; while
far from the histrionics of emo, Baxendale do a brilliant
job of conveying
the sort of all-consuming love -- whether for music
or another human being --
that makes our hearts beat faster, steals the breath from
our lungs and convinces us
that the earth is spinning at three times its normal speed.
Old-fashioned it might
be, but it's giddily infectious. Even comparatively sad
tracks like the post-breakup
anthem "Battery Acid" suggest that problems are best
confronted on the dance floor.
Baxendale aren't perfect, of course; their slower songs, in
particular, are hit-and-miss.
The strongest material here has been available on import
singles for ages, which makes
it difficult to assess the current state of Baxendale's art;
rather than finding many new
favorites, I found myself lingering over material I already
own. And the lyrics, which
at the best of times play fast and loose with the line
between charming and twee, occasionally
flop over the fence in a display of unrepentant silliness.
Fortunately, the thing that
shocked me the most -- a misunderstanding of "Contact
Lenses"' refrain that had me convinced
Tim was singing "I've lost all my defenses / since I made
contact with your menses" --
can be attributed to
Stupid-Reviewer-Who-Doesn't-Look-At-Song-Titles disease.
My fondness for Baxendale requires me to recommend this
album to everyone who
has ever sought romantic advice from a synth-pop record or
considered Anglophilia
to be the pinnacle of fashion. You cynical indie-rock types
will hate it with a
passion; it's upbeat and bouncy, driven by a child-like
sense of joy. And hopefully
there's a lot more where it came from.