REVIEWS | FEATURES | DEPARTMENTS | BOOMBOX | PODCAST | MISC
SEARCH:
splendid > reviews > 8/9/2004
Various Artists
Various Artists
Confuse Yr Idols: A Tribute to Sonic Youth
Narnack


Format Reviewed: CD

Soundclip: "New Grenada's "Eric's Trip""

Buy me now
A couple of months ago, when he heard that my son was learning guitar, a musician friend of mine offered to teach him the "Sonic Youth chord" that would magically allow my kid to sound like the legendary art-punk band. That lesson never happened, and I kind of doubt that it's really that easy. Still, there's definitely a thriving cottage industry in trying to sound like Sonic Youth -- young musicians of every stripe take aim at their inspired brand of dissonance. On a comp like Confuse Yr Idols, however, you'll find most bands trying not to sound like Sonic Youth, putting their own mark on alt-culture icons like "Death Valley '69" and "Dirty Boots". The idea is to admire without kowtowing -- pay homage without xeroxing -- and it's an interesting, if not always successful effort.

"Death Valley '69", the Lydia Lunch collaboration from Bad Moon Rising, gets two wildly different cover treatments here. Racebannon's version is fairly faithful, adding a little (more) discord with singer Michael Anderson's furious vocals. Saicobab, a side project from the Boredoms' Yoshimi, takes a few more liberties, replacing SY's indie drone with sitar-ish Eastern harmonies. Not surprisingly, Saicobab's cover stands up best, shimmering and whispering like a fuzzy mirage, only loosely related to its inspiration. However, simply changing SY's songs around won't automatically make the covers better. New Grenada doesn't exactly reinvent "Eric's Trip" -- they just put a giddy gloss on it, the girl-sung vocals making the song a lot less difficult, a lot more fun, and maybe a bit more disposable than the original.

And then there's the weird stuff, like Twink's heavily theatrical, toy-piano plunked cover of "Cinderella's Big Score". It's actually quite pretty, but about as far from the Sonic Youth source as it's possible to be. Similarly, Tub Ring's "Kool Thing" takes one of my favorite Goo tracks and turns it inside out, finding a loungey James Bond vibe and riding it roughshod over the original. Elf Power's "Kotton Krown", pleasant in a low-key, campfire song way, feels more VU-ish than SY-like with its bent acoustic notes and odd interplay.

None of these tracks will change the way you think about Sonic Youth, but a few of them might introduce you to new bands or a new way of looking at familiar songs. Think of it as extra credit, assuming that you've already done your homework and listened to most of the major Sonic Youth albums.



REVIEWS:

12/31/2005:
Ladytron

Brian Cherney

Tomas Korber

UHF

The Rude Staircase

Dian Diaz

12/30/2005:
Helloween

PTI

The Crimes of Ambition

Karl Blau

Rosetta

Gary Noland

12/29/2005:
Tommy and The Terrors

Blacklisted

Bound Stems

Gary Noland

Carlo Actis Dato and Baldo Martinez

Quatuor Bozzoni

12/28/2005:
The Positions

Comet Gain

Breadfoot featuring Anna Phoebe

Secret Mommy

The Advantage

For a Decade of Sin: 11 Years of Bloodshot Records

12/27/2005:
The Slow Poisoner

Alan Sondheim & Ritual All 770

Davenport

Beaumont

Five Corners Jazz Quintet

Cameron McGill

Drunk With Joy

12/26/2005:
10 Ft. Ganja Plant

The Hospitals

Ross Beach

Big Star

The Goslings

Lair of the Minotaur

Koji Asano



Splendid looks great in Firefox. See for yourself.
Get Firefox!


FEATURES:
Grizzly Bear's Ed Droste probably didn't even know that he'd be the subject of Jennifer Kelly's final Splendid interview... but he is!



DEPARTMENTS:
That Damn List Thing
& - The World Beyond Your Stereo
Bookshelf
Pointless Questions
File Under
Pointless Questions
& - The World Beyond Your Stereo


ARCHIVE:
Read reviews from the last 30, 60, 90 or 120 days, or search our review archive.

It's back! Splendid's daily e-mail update will keep you up to date on our latest reviews and articles. Subscribe now!
Your e-mail address:    
REVIEWS | FEATURES | DEPARTMENTS | BOOMBOX | PODCAST | MISC
SEARCH:
All content ©1996 - 2011 Splendid WebMedia. Content may not be reproduced without the publisher's permission.