Long ago, in a land far away, one could don a fresh
Sunny Day Real Estate shirt, and Converse sneakers and grow one's
sideburns long, while discussing how certain bands could
capture emotional distress in the same way that T.S.
Elliot once did. Yes, on planet 1995, one could partake
in such activities and still retain a sense of
self respect. But in case you haven't noticed, the
great emo backlash has long since begun; indie-pop is
in and profuse discussions about "feelings" are out.
I have opened this review with that recollection to
remind the reader that there was a time when
drawn-out vocals and self-consciously dynamic
breakdowns were musically relevant and somewhat
forward-moving.
Context is a
decisive factor in appreciating this self-titled Red Stars
Theory retrospective. The CD encompasses two out of
print releases -- the RxRemedy 7" and the Deluxe Records
10" -- both recorded in 1995, prior to the addition of full-time violinist Seth Warren. Engineered by
Calvin Johnson at Dub Narcotic, the disc does an
excellent job of documenting the auspices of the then
up-and-coming band -- and displays, to a much greater
extent than their later albums, the band's connection to other
members of the mid-'90s Northwest
scene (Red Stars Theory shares members with Modest Mouse and 764-Hero).
While these early recordings pale in comparison to
the orchestral dream-pop sound the band would later establish, they are by no means a total wash.
The best moments here blend hypnotic, Diary-esque vocal stylings
with transient crashing guitar interludes that
seamlessly drift in and out of consciousness, forming
an album as alluring as it is consistent.
Although the retrospective gets off to a forgettable
start with "Broken Neck" -- a song that is clearly dated
by its whiny crescendo -- the remainder of the disc grows steadily in musical strength, reaching a high point with the meandering instrumental gem "Think Piece".
Red Stars Theory is an altogether consistent and binding
listen to what is, at worst, an exceptionally
inventive and spirited "emo" band.