After a brief, disappointing tour of the majors via Rick Rubin's
American Recordings, The Mother Hips have returned with what can only be
called a "sparkling" new album. The Hips, who have a large and growing cult following in
California and beyond -- they were featured in February on the cover of
the San Francisco Chronicle's Datebook section, a widely read
arts and entertainment guide -- also have the songs and the drive to
considerably expand that fan base. Green Hills of Earth,
like Wilco's Summerteeth, combines pop melodies, golden
harmonies and sterling production to create an album that's at once
evocative of the past and utterly contemporary. "Try try try try try
not to hate me / Love love love me and my faults / Don't you underestimate
me...", goes the chorus of "Pull Us All Together", and it's hard to argue
with such a straightforwardly passive-aggressive plea.
The list of classic rock influences to be found here could go on for
a paragraph, but the Beach Boys, the Beatles and the Kinks are a few of the most obvious. There's more than a whiff
of alt-country in these songs as well, and the album stands as a close
relation to the aforementioned Wilco, who are in fact given a musical and lyrical nod in
"Smoke". But highlighting the debt The Mother Hips owe to other, older
bands grows pointless once the songs themselves begin to sink into your
subconscious. You'll soon find yourself humming along to the pure pop
of "Channel Island Girl", and might even pull out your air guitar for
the (relative) stomper "Rich Little Girl". Girls -- some from the past, others yet to come -- obviously play a significant lyrical role here. "All summer long, you have been the only person in my
song," as "Channel Island Girl" puts it.
Some of the songs run out of steam before attempting to grasp beyond
their modest reach: The gentle piano that opens "Protein Sky" leads to a
slow- to mid-tempo rhythm that remains essentially unchanged for the
duration of the song, while a great title doesn't hide the same trick
recurring later with "Sarah Bellum." These are just quibbles, though.
For fans of complex, multilayered pop, Green Hills of Earth
offers treats too numerous to mention. For the Hips themselves, it could be another
shot at the big leagues.